B y the end of the 18th century, the novel had reached its current form, paving the way for a flourishing of the genre. Early in the century, we have the books by Jane Austen , starting with Sense and Sensibility , published in 1811:
“I started off with a sense of Sense and Sensibility as a rather stereotypical novel – very much like a lot of 18th century novels that I’ve read. There is a good sister and a bad sister, and the bad sister gets reformed and everybody lives happily ever after. But as I kept rereading it, I started to realise that it is actually a very dark novel, probably the darkest of Jane Austen’s novels.” Read more...
The Best Jane Austen Books
Patricia Meyer Spacks ,
Literary Scholar
Only a few years later, Mary Shelley, daughter of the philosopher Mary Wollstonecraft , published Frankenstein , viewed by many as one of the first science fiction books and, more than two centuries later, still a great book to read for its combination of page-turning suspense and thought-provoking questions about what it means to be human.
“It wasn’t published till 1830, but she had the idea and wrote the story when she was nineteen years old, 200 years ago, in 1816…Frankenstein has a reach of imagination that is almost hysterical. She was able to pluck this idea both from her imagination and her understanding of science. She understood what Erasmus Darwin—Charles Darwin’s grandfather—was doing: experiments with electricity and the re-animation of dead objects. She was fantastically well-read, she was terribly intellectual, she was a political radical. She had no truck with modesty and restraint, or doing what was expected of her. She was going to let her imagination go as far as it possibly could. Then she defended it.” Read more...
The Best Gothic Novels
Sarah Perry ,
Novelist
The early 19th century also saw the great novels of Sir Walter Scott, now viewed as a trailblazer of the historical fiction genre, including Ivanhoe and Waverley .
By the middle of the 19th century, the Brontë sisters were in full flow, with Charlotte Brontë’s great works, Jane Eyre and Villette, and Emily’s Wuthering Heights and Anne’s The Tenant of Wildfell Hall.
Other notable 19th-century novelists recommended on Five Books include Marie-Henri Beyle, aka Stendhal , author of The Scarlet and the Black and The Charterhouse of Parma, who fought in, and was heavily influenced by, the Napoleonic Wars:
“The title of the book is a reference to the tradition in French high-born families, where the first son goes into the military—the red—and the second son going into the priesthood—the black. I think this is one of the most wicked books on social climbing ever written…It’s the story of a young man of humble birth from the provinces, Julien Sorel.” Read more...
The Best Historical Fiction Set in France
David Lawday ,
Biographer
Also in French literature, we have Victor Hugo and his magnum opus, Les Misérables :
“I read Les Misérables when I was a kid and then re-read it last summer and…I am now convinced that it is the greatest novel of all time. Every story in the world is somewhere in there. It’s extremely sentimental, it’s extremely historical and digressive, there are parts of it that are boring as hell – but that’s true of War and Peace and other great novels. Overall, it’s such a compendious, wonderful thing, full of gems…He was in exile on the island of Guernsey from where he could almost see France on a clear day. And one big dimension of Les Misérables is it’s a novel of nostalgia – he’s trying to reconstruct the Paris of his youth” Read more...
The Greatest French Novels
David Bellos ,
Biographer
“It’s a very impressive novel and stunningly modern as well. It also has to do with the origins of colonial exploitation – the story of the money is the story of Algeria actually. Balzac had an intuitive understanding of where corruption was to be found, where what was going on was really dirty. And he really pulled out all the stops to give us this portrait of a society that was rotten to the core.” Read more...
The Greatest French Novels
David Bellos ,
Biographer
Another great 19th-century French novelist was Alexandre Dumas, author of The Three Musketeers and the great revenge tale, The Count of Montecristo:
“It’s a tale as old as time: boy meets girl, boy is wrongly imprisoned for many years, boy escapes, discovers enormous fortune on mysterious Mediterranean island, boy exacts revenge on the people who locked him up in the first place. It was a lockdown read for me: it’s 1200 closely-typed pages, and surprisingly thrilling given how long it is.” Read more...
Novels of the Rich and Wealthy
Andrew Hunter Murray ,
Comedians & Humorist
Of books by Charles Dickens , the most frequently recommended on Five Books is Great Expectations, his exploration of the morality of money and featuring Pip as the much-loved main protagonist:
“It is one of the most perfect novels ever written.It’s got a wonderful plot. It’s about good and bad money, you don’t know who Pip’s benefactor is, you’re wrong-footed—as he is—all the time. It’s about terrible damage. It’s got this fantastic suspense about what happens to Magwitch. It’s sad, but also it’s got wonderful humour in it and wonderful characters. It’s got Wemmick, one of the first commuters. It’s just brilliant.” Read more...
The Best Charles Dickens Books
Jenny Hartley ,
Biographer
“Not only is Eliot a great moral thinker—you feel the movement of a philosophically sophisticated ethicist moving behind the scenes of Middlemarch—but it’s also about the use of literature in moving us morally forward…It’s not only my favourite philosophical novel, it’s my favourite novel. I teach it again and again and each time I am flabbergasted by what she’s able to accomplish and what my students get out of it.” Read more...
The Best Philosophical Novels
Rebecca Goldstein ,
Philosopher
The most recommended of the 19th-century US novels are:
“I chose the book largely because I think Mark Twain…is a major innovator: he expanded our sense of what the nineteenth-century U.S. novel could do, all while dramatizing how slavery’s legacy persisted into Reconstruction and the Gilded Age—and on into the present day. Almost everything beautiful and troubling about this novel comes back to Twain’s complex decision to focalize a tale of shocking brutality through the perspective of a child.” Read more...
The Best 19th-Century American Novels
Nathan Wolff ,
Literary Scholar
“I thought about responding to your call for a list of the top 5 American novels with ‘1) Moby-Dick 2) Moby-Dick 3) Moby-Dick’ —an obsessive answer that would be true to the spirit of this monomaniacal book! I won’t go full Ahab and claim that it is THE great American novel, but I will confess it is my favorite. There’s something about its dizzying mix of high and low, Herman Melville’s exuberant love of language, and the novel’s remarkable capaciousness (everything reminds me of Moby-Dick !) that makes me love to read it, reread it, teach it, joke about it, tweet about it, reference it at the slightest provocation.” Read more...
The Best 19th-Century American Novels
Nathan Wolff ,
Literary Scholar
“it’s a story about the institution of marriage, and the diminished sphere of choice that was available to women at the time. Stories about marriage are clearly not just stories about love—sometimes not even stories about love. Marriage as a social institution, marriage as a form of power—these are at the heart of the story here. Even Isabel Archer’s seduction by Osmond is a narrative that is one of power rather than romance.” Read more...
Katie Kitamura on Marriage (and Divorce) in Literature
Katie Kitamura ,
Journalist
Books by Leo Tolstoy , the great Russian writer of the 19th century, include:
“Although he set out to write a moralising novel showing the evils of Anna’s adultery, his human empathy pushed him in a very different direction, and the reader sees every step towards the final tragedy from Anna’s point of view and sees how difficult—perhaps impossible—any of the alternatives would have been.” Read more...
The best books on Moral Philosophy
Jonathan Glover ,
Philosopher
Others prefer Fyodor Dostoevsky and his masterpieces, Crime and Punishment and The Brothers Karamazov:
“The Brothers Karamazov is a real detective novel, a very rare phenomenon for 19th-century Russian fiction. We have a mysterious murder here, we have several suspects, we have a courtroom investigation, and we do not know eventually, not for sure, who is the culprit.” Read more...
Five Mysteries Set in Russia
Boris Akunin ,
Thriller and Crime Writer
“I think what he’s writing is a comedy of manners. But he’s also writing about the way the world is. He’s very alert to the changes in society, the Industrial Revolution and the declining power of the landed aristocracy, of which he was the poor cousin. He had to work. He’s the perfect person to be narrating these scenes. It is a real tapestry of Britain in the 19th century, but with a lot of things to say about our times as well. You learn a lot about life, really, and our lives, through reading someone like Trollope.” Read more...
The Best Anthony Trollope Books
Francesca Simon ,
Children's Author
One of the great horror tales dates from 1897:
“I like to read Dracula as one of the great novels of London. Stoker himself was an Irish immigrant to London. The Count is a central European immigrant to London. He initially moves to Carfax Abbey, in the suburbs, before gentrifying himself and moving to Piccadilly.” Read more...
The Best Horror Stories
Darryl Jones ,
Literary Scholar
If you love mystery novels, you can’t go wrong with books by Wilkie Collins . He claimed that on his gravestone would be written “author of The Woman in White “:
“It’s credited with being the beginning of the whole genre of suspense. That’s why I picked it. I’ve only read it twice, but it’s lingered in my consciousness: the images and the feel of it. He really is a master of the tricks. I read somewhere that there are 40 cliff-hangers in it—he sort of invented the cliff-hanger. And I like the Russian doll structure of all the different accounts. You gradually lift off each little doll’s body and find another plot strand and another secret. I love that. It’s very cleverly done.” Read more...
The Best Classic Thrillers
Lucy Atkins ,
Novelist
Finally in fiction , a few classic children’s books were published in the 19th century, including:
“It’s about, of course, a girl who falls down a rabbit hole into a strange world populated by strange creatures. You’d have to be a zombie to miss the humour in it – it’s hilarious. Although the book is ancient the humour feels modern.” Read more...
The best books on Comic Writing
Larry Doyle ,
Comedians & Humorist
“I find it odd that people don’t realise how revolutionary this book is…It was the first book that gave consciousness and personality to an animal, which is the horse, Black Beauty. It is narrated in the first person and is supposedly his autobiography. Black Beauty starts off life with a loving mother and great happiness and a good owner. Then he gets sold from one person to another and it is a terrible tragic story of the erosion of happiness and health, until finally, when broken-down and near death from ill-treatment, he is rescued. So it is a story of paradise lost, and regained.” Read more...
Books that Changed the World
Amanda Craig ,
Journalist
Also of note were the adventure books by Robert Louis Stevenson, as well as his work of Gothic horror:
“Lots and lots of people know the phrase, that ‘Jekyll and Hyde’ means a split personality: good on one side, evil on the other. They might even have seen one or two film adaptations of the book. But I think one of the things that would surprise folk who haven’t read the original book, first of all, is that it’s very short. It’s a novella, only about 150 pages long, yet it’s dealing with such amazingly deep themes.” Read more...
Landmarks of Scottish Literature
James Robertson ,
Novelist
The French writer Jules Verne was also originally marketed in the English-speaking world as a children’s author, though he is now often seen through a science fiction lens:
“The book has just enough science that it seems real. If you read it as a kid and re-read it as a geologist, you think there are some very interesting things in there.
He plays around with certain facts. He comes up with a very interesting theory to explain that it doesn’t get hot as you go deeper underground (which was in vogue at the time), but the book imagines the preservation of prehistoric life in the subsurface and that’s something we’re still looking at. Many of the organisms that we find down there today look to be, from an evolutionary point of view, extremely primitive. The conditions we find them in are very much what the surface of the Earth used to look like, three billion years ago. There is no oxygen and three billion years ago there was very little oxygen on the surface of our planet.” Read more...
The best books on Life Below the Surface of the Earth
Tullis Onstott ,
Environmentalist
NONFICTION BOOKS
As readers immersed themselves in sensational or heartbreaking tales by reading fiction, nonfiction books also saw some landmarks written in the 19th century. The best place to start with books by German philosopher Karl Marx is probably his Communist Manifesto:
“I chose The Communist Manifesto , rather than, say, Capital because it shows in a much easier-to-read, shorter work something that is central to Marx’s vision. .. The Communist Manifesto is an early work, published in February 1848, the year of revolutions in Europe, when Marx was not quite 30. The Manifesto shows Marx still thinking within the framework of Hegel’s ideas about contradiction but transforming them from something that’s happening in our consciousness to something that’s happening in the material world.” Read more...
The Best Nineteenth-Century Philosophy Books
Peter Singer ,
Philosopher
The same year, 1859, also saw the publication of John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty, the classic statement of liberal values. It remains more relevant than ever and is one of our most recommended books on Five Books :
“What this book does is hammer home one truth. Mill described it as a ‘philosophic textbook of a single truth’. According to him it was hugely influenced by his discussions with his wife, Harriet Taylor, though she didn’t physically write it, and it’s his name on the cover. As the title suggests, it’s focused on liberty, on freedom. It puts forward what’s come to be known as ‘the harm principle’ which is that the only justification for the state or other people interfering with the lives of adults is if they risk harming others with their actions” Read more...
Key Philosophical Texts in the Western Canon
Nigel Warburton ,
Philosopher
Other notable nonfiction works of the 19th century include books by the French statesman Alexis de Tocqueville , who wrote about both what made American democracy flourish and what caused the French Revolution:
“What’s striking is that he is able to develop broad analytical categories that relate the French Revolution to the direction of modern society as a whole, which he sees as the destruction of the aristocracy and the coming of democracy. But he adds a twist that will remain influential to this day, which is that he points to the weakness of democracy as a form of government. It has an internal, inherent tendency to lead to despotism unless there are certain conditions that prevent that from happening.” Read more...
The best books on The French Revolution
Lynn Hunt ,
Historian
Also of note is the theory of warfare laid out by the Prussian general, Carl von Clausewitz, in his book On War— still key reading if you’re interested in military strategy books:
In the sciences, meanwhile, Charles Darwin’s books shattered a millennia-old worldview that saw life as created by god by introducing his theory of evolution by natural selection.
“An educated person is someone who knows at least a little bit about the major disciplines in human endeavour. And in biology, this is what you need to know – not only historically but also contemporaneously, because Darwin was right, and still is right, about so many things.” Read more...
The best books on Evolution
Jerry Coyne ,
Biologist
Finally, published in 1890—but still recommended on Five Books by psychologists—is William James’s Principles of Psycholog y:
“A wonderful summary of what was known and what questions were being asked at the dawn of psychology as a science in the 19th century. James is widely mis-cited and misunderstood as someone who advocated for a classical, common sense view of emotion. The irony is that he advocated for just the opposite.” Read more...
The Best Books on Emotions
Lisa Feldman Barrett ,
Psychologist
Five Books aims to keep its book recommendations and interviews up to date. If you are the interviewee and would like to update your choice of books (or even just what you say about them) please email us at [email protected]
Five Books interviews are expensive to produce. If you've enjoyed this interview, please support us by donating a small amount .